Saturday, December 8, 2007

Did you get my note?

Since time has become such a factor in the next round of Board decisions, I sent a message to every email address I could get from last year's Dolphin Directory.

I heard from some people that they received my message, but some others said their email clients screened it out as potential spam. For those of you who didn't receive my note, here is what it said:

Dear Parent,

I apologize for sending this mass email, but I felt recent developments in the proposed merger of Hillsborough and Central elementary schools warranted such a step. Time is of the essence, and this is the fastest way to communicate with such a large community.

My name is Allan Scott, and my son is a second-grader at HES. Those who know me are aware that I have paid very close attention to the Orange County Board of Education’s efforts to merge HES with CES for over 9 months. While I regularly post developments to my weblog (http://SaveHES.blogspot.com), I have not felt the need to email everyone since last spring; that is, until now.

Every parent with a child in Orange County's elementary schools needs to know that the Board of Education is poised to create an entirely new plan for changing CES and HES that will likely impact every elementary school in the district. And this dramatic change will probably happen with virtually no input from those most directly impacted – the parents. If the Board continues in its current direction, there will be no time for research or debate, and almost no opportunity for public comment.

This past Monday, Board members proposed four entirely new proposals for changes to CES and HES. Among these were:

  • Requiring every current HES student to “reapply” for admission, with a cap on the number of students from any one school zone and quotas for those allowed to return. According to the plan, this cap could prevent as many as 80 current HES students from returning to the only school many of them have ever known.
  • Capping HES enrollment at 330 and redistricting the remaining 100 students to CES. New students would only be allowed to enroll at HES if a similar number chose to attend CES.
  • Recinding all transfers not mandated by federal law. This means that parents who applied for, and were granted transfers, for their children to schools outside their zone would be forced to return unless they can prove an "extreme hardship." This represents over 100 children with a sizable number at all six zoned schools. No elementary school would be unaffected.
  • Closing CES for an entire year and “distributing” all CES students to other elementary schools, again taking them away from the only school many of them have ever known.
  • Eliminating Kindergarten at HES and only allowing children to apply after spending one year at their zoned school.
  • Taking $300,000 in federal funding away from reading teachers at CES and Efland-Cheeks Elementary School as a way to disguise the fact that neither school made Adequate Yearly Progress the past two years.

While many ideas have been put forth over the past 9 months, we are now at a point where time has become a critical factor. Recognizing that, Board Chairman Ted Triebel was recently quoted as saying, “We’re in a time crunch here, and I think everybody knows it.”

In response, he scheduled a two-hour special session to discuss proposed changes to CES and HES. That meeting is scheduled for Friday, December 14th at 8:30 am in the Central Office Boardroom on King Street in Hillsborough.

To make matters worse, the Board decided Monday night to set January 20, 2008 as the deadline to approve final changes to CES and HES before the next school year. Given that they have not yet had any in-depth discussion of any plan other than a CES/HES merger, any new idea would have only six weeks to be discussed, accepted and approved.

As it stands, the Board does not have another regular meeting until January 7th. – less than two weeks before its self-imposed deadline. That means that any idea to come out of the December 14th meeting will likely be approved by the Board in January, regardless of how ill-conceived it may be or how negatively it may impact the District's elementary schools.

It is important that parents at both schools take the few remaining opportunities to voice their opinions before it is too late. If you know any CES parents, parents new to HES, or those who have transfered their children to a school outside their zone, feel free to forward this message to them.

I understand that the time and day of week is difficult for many, but I encourage everyone who can, to attend the Board’s special meeting next Friday morning, and let your presence send a message to the Board.

Will you join me there?

If you are unable to attend, please contact your elected Board of Education members to let them know how you feel. You can find email addresses for all members here: http://www.orange.k12.nc.us/board/ocs_board_edu.html .

Sincerely,

Allan Scott

Save the Date!
What: Orange County Board of Education CES/HES Special Meeting
When: Friday, December 14, 2007 @ 8:30 am in the Central Office Boardroom
200 King Street
Hillsborough, NC 27278

21 comments:

Anonymous said...

Many kindergarten parents will not be able to come because the kindergarten is having a holiday program at 9:00 Fri morning. Everyone, please email your board members if you are unable to come!!!

Anonymous said...

Everyone should email their friends incase they didn't get this email.

Anonymous said...

There is a meeting tonight (Monday) from 5-7 too! It is on the orange county schools website.

Anonymous said...

I'm unclear whether public comments will be accepted. Does anyone know?

Anonymous said...

They usually only have public comments at their regular meetings.

Anonymous said...

I'm sure Ted will quash any attempts for anyone to speak at the public meeting. Anyway, no one listens.

Anonymous said...

Lots of classrooms will be having celebrations. Perhaps this is the point to...I'm sure the meeting will be going on well after the 9:00 program. Please get there to tell the board what you think...

Anonymous said...

This is a perfect time for the Board members to screw the families at HES and CES. They can have their vote, and then run out of town. Too bad the members cannot display the character that everyone in our community could admire.

Anonymous said...

Scott,
You should send out a mass email encouraging everyone at HES to apply for Free and Reduced Lunches (FRL) if they feel they may qualify, even if they don't intend to actually purchase a free or reduced fee lunch. Many folks who qualify have not filled out the paperwork for various reasons. Some eligible parents have made the choice (yes, we folks at HES have a track record of exercising CHOICE!)to pack a healthier lunch than what the school system provides. Our failure to complete the application has caused the FRL numbers to be skewed. For example, a family of 4 with a gross income of less than $38,200 may qualify for FRL. Our school may no longer be on the chopping block when our numbers veer closer to the board's target of 38% FRL. Do not worry about embarrassment or pride issues. Your privacy is assured and your school will be saved!
Here's the link for application:
http://www.orange.k12.nc.us/
support_services/Childnutrition/2007%20NC%20Free%20%20Reduced%20Application%20REVISED.pdf

Anonymous said...

WOW! What a rush of power has gone thru the veins of Ted! This is military power at its best. He hates it when anyone questions his authority. This is not leadership--this is arrogance. Ted, it's not too late to learn the difference...

Anonymous said...

Ted finally has a chance to assert his power over others--been missing it for years. He is harmless--all of his ideas have come from other Board Members.

What got me mad was that Ted did not thank the Task Force for their input with this solution. I know he's not a leader, but I at least thought he had some class.

Anonymous said...

The CES teachers should be thanking the Board for not shaking up the school. The teachers should feel fortunate that they are not being judged by the test scores, but instead by the SES makeup within their classroom.

Anonymous said...

I don't understand the last comment about the CES teachers should be thanking the board. Anyone judging the teachers at CES should be ignored - or worse.

The board has essentially sent a message that their major concerns are HES does have enough FRL kids and that they really don't want to suffer the inconvenience of letting kids opt out.

The students of our district now know that test scores really don't matter (congrats to Liz Brown) and that rather than focus on fixing schools, the board wants to provide preschool for the kids in the county.

I'm just too dumbfounded to think clearly. Every voter in this county should be working on a recall vote for the BOE.

The kids that will suffer the most are the very ones who need the most help and not from subsidized pre-k programs. Students who failed EOGs have not been given one shred of extra support. Good Lord, can we get over the FRL percentages at HES and care about the whole freakin' failing district?

Anonymous said...

HES FAMILIES ARE BEING BLAMED FOR THE TEST SCORES WITHIN CES!!! WHY EVEN MESS WITH HES!!! CES NEEDS TO COME UP WITH STRATEGIES TO IMPROVE THE CLASSROOM!!!

SOLUTION: CLOSE CES.

Anonymous said...

I too am dumbfounded. Shouldn't the board of EDUCATION be more focused on EDUCATION? I think we need a Board composed of educators. Perhaps then we might have a group that could focus on education and not the color or income of the families in Orange Co.

Thanks Liz for not caring about the failing children at CES. One would assume that you don't care about the failing children at any of our other schools either. Take your political agenda and promote it elsewhere. As one CES parent boldly stated, you are creating a race issue where there isn't one. It has been noted time and time again you are a Harvard graduate. I think all of us are at loss as to how such a well-educated woman could state that Central's test scores don't matter at all. I think you owe the entire school population an explanation for that comment.

Kudos to Anne and Al for trying to do their best to promote a plan that would actually involve EDUCATING the failing kids of our county.

Anonymous said...

A cursory glance at recall procedures indicates that it wouldn't be that hard. File an form, collect 25% of the voting population's signatures within 30 days and return it to central office.

I think that with this latest move, the BOE has pretty much alienated everyone in the county so 25% should be very easy.

We could place someone at Wal-mart, at Food Lion and it a couple of places in Mebane.

Any thoughts?

Tink's Mom

Anonymous said...

To Tink's Mom;

It's time to move on. I don't have the time nor the energy to fight the Board. Not that they are not inept, but we will look like idiots if we proceed with that idea.

If we are to shed our elitist persona, we need to focus on the big picture (re-election) and make the Board members toe the line. Their decision on Friday was not what they wanted.

Anonymous said...

Okay, but I thought only Dennis, Al and Liz will be rolling off. Doesn't that mean that we are stuck with Ted for another year or two?

I hate to jinx us, but it would be damned near impossible to do worse than Dennis and Liz. I'll refrain from saying anymore than that.

Do the parents of Central children realize that the decision really skirts the issues at their school and does not implement any plan to help them? Just curious.

Tink's Mom

Anonymous said...

Contact:
Michael Gilbert
Public Information Officer
Orange County Schools
Phone: 919-732-8126
Fax: 919-732-8120
Email: michael.gilbert@orange.k12.nc.us

December 14, 2007

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:

Orange County Board of Education Develops Plan to Address Central and Hillsborough Elementary Schools

Hillsborough, NC- The Orange County Board of Education met on Friday, December 14, 2007, to discuss and determine a plan to provide improved socio-economic balance and educational opportunities at Central Elementary and Hillsborough Elementary Schools. Following several months of deliberation, the Orange County Board of Education by a 5-2 vote, approved a plan to address and improve the socio-economic status of Central and Hillsborough Elementary Schools.

Under the newly adopted plan, federal Title I funds will be focused on providing district-wide pre-kindergarten classrooms to promote educational readiness for at-risk pre-schoolers to help ensure their cognitive readiness to start kindergarten. This shift in Title I funds will not result in reductions to staffing or services to students.
The Board of Education agreed to provide additional support to Central Elementary School through the maintenance of relatively small class size, ensuring that the transfer policy is strictly adhered to and by developing university and business partnerships. Furthermore, the District will implement further strategies to improve achievement levels. The Board has suggested investigating possible ideas for a themed school, aesthetic improvements to the school facility, along with academic program enhancements.

To address the socio-economic status of Hillsborough Elementary School, the Board of Education moved to revise the registration process and limit enrollment of HES population to 20% of each schools’ attendance zone. A priority for admission will be given to all low-income students. Rising third, fourth and fifth grade students enrolled in Hillsborough Elementary School and their siblings will be grandfathered and allowed to remain at HES. All rising kindergarten, first, and second grade students will be required to register or re-register under the new [cut] procedures. Any student who has opted to attend Hillsborough Elementary School under Title I School Choice may remain enrolled, without undergoing the registration process.

To encourage lower socio-economic students to apply to Hillsborough Elementary School, the District will expand transportation opportunities and create intersession programs at little to no cost to qualified participants.

Beginning today and over the course of the next months, Orange County Schools district-level staff and selected principals will be engaged in developing the implementation of the Board’s plan. Staff will generate more specific details, relevant timeliness, and action steps will be provided during future Board and planning meetings.
The Orange County Board of Education agreed to evaluate annually the progress the District has made in addressing the socio-economic balance.
According to Superintendent Patrick Rhodes “The Board of Education has put a great deal of time and thought into addressing the issue of socio-economic balance and academic opportunities at these two schools. Our staff is ready to move forward with implementation of this plan and we will make every effort to ensure its success"

Anonymous said...

Interesting that the release does not say that Efland Cheeks and Central students will no longer be granted the option to leave the school as mandated by NCLB guidelines.

So if you are in first grade at HES, non-FRL, have no older sibling and are districted to Central or Efland Cheeks, you will probably not get back into HES and will be forced to go to your districted school.

Also, for those students who opted out this year b/c of NCLB, you have the legal right to remain at the new school, however, the county does not have to provide transportation. Hopefully, this caveat will not come to pass. They voted on it on Friday, but maybe they are having second thoughts.

Anonymous said...

Wow, the poor parents of the children who opted out, opted out under the impression that they would have transportation provided didn't they?

What a mess this has created for all of you. Now you don't know where your children will be attending school next year unless you are fortunate enough to have children in grades 3-5.

Good Luck to all of you!!